Search This Blog

Showing posts with label turkey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label turkey. Show all posts

Monday, 17 August 2026

There are Rivers in the Sky - Elif Şafak

 Elif Şafak’tan bir roman yeni okudum, ‘There are Rivers in the Sky’.  Onu okudum 

ama sonunda onu bitiremedim.  Romanın temaların arasında su eksikliği, Yezidiler ve azınlıklara yönelik zulüm, arazı tahsısı, kapitalizm, kültürel hırsızlık, cinsiyet politikası, ISIS, ortadoğu'nun unutmuş veya hiç bilinmemiş kültürel zenginliği, bağımlılık, insan organlarının satışı ve başkalar yer alıyor - aslında o kadar temalar var ki bütünları hatırlayamazsın.   Ama maalesef bu tema zenginliği romanın zayıf noktalarından biri.  Şafak bugünkü en popüler, en şık temaları, meseleleri toplanmış gibi ve hepsini romanına tıkıştırdı.  Bu temalar aslında çok önemli ve günümüzle ilgilidir.  Her tema değerli ve ilginç olabilir, ama maalesef bir romanda o kadar var ki onlar iyi bir şekilde geliştirilmezler.  Sonunda bu bir satış strateji veya erdem gösterisine benziyor.  

Ek olarak karakterlerin çoğu biraz stereotipik görünüyorlar.  Her biri bir davranışın, bir bakış açısının bir simgesi gibidir.  Nihayetinde, bu roman ağır ve derin temalarla dolu olmasına rağmen, sığ bir roman olarak kalıyor.                 


Thursday, 10 June 2021

Orange - Orhan Pamuk

 A collection of night photos taken on his walks through Istanbul.  Interesting idea and some of the photos are good, but this is a book that would never have been published if it were someone less well-known.  The idea is interesting, the light and the street scenes have potential, but there is not enough variety in the material to justify such a large collection of images.  

Worth a look, but not a book to cherish.

Tuesday, 23 June 2020

Twice a Stranger - Bruce Clark

Subtitled:  How Mass Expulsion Forged Modern Greece and Turkey.

An excellent account of this whole historical episode.  It gives the background and the historical information in detail, but not too much.  It also includes many personal reminiscences of the experience from older people on both sides of the divide, as well as acute observations from the author made during his travels in both countries.
The end result is a complex picture of a complex set of experiences which tends to counter the more absolute mythology around the expulsions and the events leading up to them. 

One interesting passage can be found on pp. 193 - 195, recounting the political moves of the CHP around the opposition that was critical of the government's corruption and inefficiency in dealing with the population exchange.  In the end, the leaders of the opposition were accused of being disloyal and imprisoned and eventually executed during the aftermath of the Kurdish uprising shortly after the population exchange.  The press was also so suppressed.  The ruling party even maintained they had aborted an assassination attempt on Atatürk   This is, of course, the identical playbook that Erdoğan has used - the Ergenkon case, as well as the whole Fetah Gülen story.  Various aspects of the Turkish managing of the population exchange make it clear that this collusion between the ruling party and the big business elite is built into the DNA of the Turkish Republic.  In a way, it is a continuation of the relationship between the Sultan and the non-Muslim elites of the late Ottoman Empire - a favoured business elite with special rapport with the government and which is allowed to enrich itself in exchange for money and favours...   As usual, nations have a very hard time changing their political DNA;  they just swap round the power brokers and the business elite groups.

Tuesday, 5 November 2019

Berji Kristin: Tales from the Garbage Hills - Latife Tekin

A fascinating social portrait of a time and place - the period of mass migration from Anatolian villages to Istanbul and Ankara, and the creation of massive overnight slum neighbourhoods.  A portrait of the village mind in confrontation with capitalism and the effects of untrammelled industrialization.  Also a portrait of capital at work in the neoliberal post 60s military coup in Turkey.  Dovetails nicely with another book I read recently - Why Turkey is Authoritarian:  From Atatürk to Erdoğan, by Halil Karaveli.  The novel puts some flesh and bones onto the political situation of the time - government unquestioning support of capital, ignored corruption, links between politics and organized crime, suppression of worker rights.

Friday, 16 August 2019

Dear Shameless Death - Latife Tekin

    A novel based on the author's experience as a child of moving to the big city (Istanbul or Ankara) from her small isolated village in Anatolia.  Many parts of the novel read like surrealism or magic realism but in large part I think instead it reflects the "magical" thinking of childhood and of people deeply embedded in a world of tradition, superstition and folk religion.  I especially enjoyed the character of the young girl, Dermit, and think the author does an amazing job of entering into the perceptions and thinking of childhood, which is very hard for rational adults.

Thursday, 8 August 2019

How Fascism Works - Jason Stanley

A well-written concise book looking at the way fascism/autocratic forms of government establish themselves in a democratic context.  Step by step, technique by technique analysis.  Reads like a "how to" manual for would-be dictators.
Each critical step draws examples from history, mostly Mussolini and Hitler, and then looks at these same steps being taken currently in various countries around the world from the U.S. to Turkey to Russia to many others.
It is both interesting and useful to look at these steps and ask which ones you see currently operating within your own society.  Kind of a social health check-up. 
Worth reading several times.
Also worth reading in tandem with Ece Temelkuran's recent book, "How to Lose a Country".

How to Lose a Country - Ece Temelkuran

Subtitled "The 7 Steps from Democracy to Dictatorship"
    Brilliant book chronicling Turkey's slide into its current dictatorship/autocracy, with asides looking at the same process in other countries - U.S., Hungary, Russia, Poland, Britain.
She brings up the point that this structure of government can actually be called a form of mafia government.
     A good companion read to "How Fascism Works".
    Temelkuran points out some interesting techniques used by would-be leaders, particularly their use of the news cycle and the outrageous statement as a means to controlling the media's and people's attention, directing it towards controversial topics as the government gets on with some other agenda that it doesn't want attention on.
    A very disturbing book.  You have to worry about your own homeland heading in that direction. So far, Temelkuran has focused on the actions of the would-be dictator as he moves towards absolute power, but I am interested in the ground, the socio-political situation that makes his rise possible, that he exploits on his way up.  My sense is the fertile ground lies in groups that see themselves excluded from the benefits of society as it stands.  And it has to be a significant group in terms of numbers.  When I consider Turkey, Russia and Hungary, it seems that desperate poverty is certainly one of those conditions of exclusion.  Hence, the aspiring fascist/dictator groups get the support of these poor people by simply giving them some of the basic necessities of life for free. (Same thing was done in Egypt by the Muslim Brotherhood - these poor people may not buy into the religious or nationalist message, but they sure appreciate the food and other necessities.)  Or by creating low-paying fake jobs for them - as Orban is doing in Hungary.  This, however, is not one of the basic techniques in the U.S. - their mythology is too strongly against any kind of social welfare...
So you can conclude here that increased income inequality, either within society as a whole or regionally, is one key element that helps prepare the ground for the rise of autocrats.
     Another group to exploit would seem to be the people who see themselves excluded for religious or cultural reasons.  In Turkey, the religious factor is obviously at play in several ways.  First in the former dominance of a secular elite.  Second, in some discriminatory laws around religious clothing that excluded people from higher education and government positions.  Cultural exclusion can also be seen. At play, I suspect, was also a disdain towards the people and society of smaller, more traditional Anatolian towns and villages, which also suffered, coincidentally from higher levels of poverty.  A would-be dictator gets their support by appearing to take them seriously, by speaking their cultural language, by granting them respect.  Which "respect" also seems to be a big selling point for Trump in the eyes of many mid-western and small town Americans (who also experience higher levels of poverty and joblessness.)
    A third issue also seems to be exploitable by would-be autocrats, the issue of "the other", of immigrants, (or of the "foreign" E.U regulations in some European countries).  It is essentially a reverse side of cultural exclusion  - the fear of becoming a cultural stranger in your own country due to immigrant culture or culture imposed from outside. This is the issue that can be used with the middle-class, secular citizen. This trope is being exploited in many countries, but alone it doesn't seem to get the would-be autocrat too far.  Economic exclusion and cultural exclusion seem to be more powerful issues to exploit.

    The other interesting idea she brings up, which is peculiar to our current technology and era, is the idea of the mob - how harsh it can be, how dangerous, how beyond reason.  In situations like that of Turkey (and the U.S.) Twitter etc. essentially function as tools for the formation of mobs at lightening speed.  The mob follows you everywhere because it infiltrates your online life.  It can also easily track your address, your family and connections.  This is a new and very scary tool for enforcing conformism and for silencing dissent through fear.

Thursday, 18 July 2019

Madonna in a Fur Coat - Sabahattin Ali

Turkish writer born in southern Bulgaria, not too far from Smolyan during the last years of the Ottoman Empire.  This book was published shortly before his death/murder in '48.  Interesting in the same way that Tanpınar is interesting.  It is interesting to the see the early writers of the new Turkish literature confronting and working with the genres and styles of Western literature.  This novel reminds me of some of the romantic work published in France and Germany in the late 18th and early 19th century - tortured souls who feel alone and alienated, doomed romantic love.  In this particular novel, with what is almost a reversal of traditional male and female roles, also represents some kind of a social revolution or challenge to traditional Turkish society of the time.  Ali had some seminal experiences in Berlin apparently, some time before the war, that shaped his politics and social views.  Seems he was a socialist and must have had very liberated social views around men's  and women's roles in society.
Not a particularly enjoyable read for me, as I don't really like that "tortured soul" Western tradition or genre, but a very interesting read when place in its historical and social context.

Also found an article about him in the Guardian - seems this book is one of the most popular in Turkey right now.  Interesting discussion of why.

Wednesday, 3 July 2019

Ahlat Ağacı - Nuri Bilge Ceylan

Another beautifully realized film by this great director.  Set in the Çanakkale area.
Very much a film of ideas, and the superb filming and framing serves to support and maintain your interest.  A lot of the films ideas are actually developed through dialogue between the main character and various groups. (Reminds me a bit of the film, "My Dinner with André".
The main character is a young man trying to figure out what direction to take in his life, what to believe in amongst the many possibilities/perspectives within his surrounding society.
There is an ongoing tension with his father who has also lost his way and seems addicted to gambling.  There are conversations with buddies doing military service, young village imams, a young woman from his town about to marry for money, a small-time author, local businessmen, local politicians.  There is a deep critical look at many of these aspects of society, an awareness of how narrow and essentially selfish/self-serving these attitudes are.
Can be a bit depressing, but the ending is hopeful in an interesting way.

The Flea Palace - Elif Şafak

Read this before, long ago.
Essentially a social portrait/social criticism of Turkish society in the complex, overlapping world of modern Istanbul.  Hits on leftists, pious groups, gays, cynical westernized leftist academics, rich profligates, poor Anatolian immigrants, the cleaning obsessed, elderly crazies, various kinds of family dynamics, cats, garbage problem, social and sexual mores, the "Ukranian wives" thing.
Humorous critique.
Bit of a tale within a tale, but not so successful/essential from that point of view.

The Time of Mute Swans - Ece Temelkuran

A novel set in Ankara during the late 70's, early 80's, when there was almost open warfare between left and right.  Told from the perspective of a young boy whose family lives in a gecekondu, and a girl living in a middle-class left-leaning family.   It looks at several things:  1) the general tenor and feeling of the time  2) the awkward relationship between the poor working class and the leftist intellectuals  3) generational differences in perspective on life, politics (and other things)  4)  some of the violence perpetrated by rightist groups   5) The lack of understanding between various groups within the society, and the resulting backstabbing 6) corruption amongst both the military and the political class
Overall, the adults in the book do not show well, being obsessed with their own agendas and concerns, as seen by the little people looking on.

In spite of these themes, it presents a very touching and human perspective on the various main characters in the book.

As an aside, Temelkuran is a persona non grata currently in Erdoğan's Turkey. 

Tuesday, 21 May 2019

A Mind at Peace - Ahmet Hamdi Tanpınar

   Not an easy read - at times slow, at times too didactic,  at times at bit scattered - but never-the-less a very interesting book for many reasons.   Mostly due to Tanpınar's position as one of the first writers of the new Turkish Republic, and his position as a writer who crosses over between the old Ottoman (and Anatolian) culture and Western culture.
   (Aside from all of this, the book is a wonderful portrait of Istanbul in its last days as an Imperial, sophisticated city with a culture and life all its own.  A time when the Boğaz villages were true villages and people spoke of going into the city as a real trip.  Both a visual portrait of how that city was, and also a social portrait of a certain lifestyle.)

  From a stylistic perspective, the book shifts through several different ones.  At times it read like Aldous Huxley's novels of ideas (Huxley is actually referenced in the novel), at times like a long interior monologue of impressions and sensations, at the end even like a kind of Magic Realism with a long scene where the main character, Mümtaz,  interacts with his recently dead acquaintance.  I wonder if this comes with the the rush to confront and absorb the West at the time of the collapse of Ottoman culture with its ties to the traditions of the East - almost a rabid desire to know and absorb this new Other.
   Also, a social drama built around a love story, where you see the confrontation of old and new values imposed on the lovers by the various people in their social circle.  A subtle confrontation, however, which does not divide along the lines of youth and age - witness Nuran's uncle, Tevfik, who is wholly supportive of their relationship.  In fact, most of the objections come from their younger circle of friends.
   Ihsan, Mümtaz's uncle, is the source of much of the novel of ideas passages, where Tanpınar, overtly explores the many social issues and shifts that must take place, or are in fact taking place, in order to build a new society with a new unifying vision or mythology.   Interesting, as these shifts also form a major part of the plot line itself.
   Another side of the book explores the feelings of nostalgia for a lost culture, with its lost heroes and figures of cultural importance.   Also, for the very culture itself, especially Ottoman classical music, which plays an important part throughout the book.  Many classical pieces and makams are referenced, from within a perspective of the subtle culture around these pieces and makams - it is possible to find some of the references on Youtube and Turkish music sites (Neyzen).

   At one point Tanpınar points out the very "hüzün" condition of his generation and social class - they live within a culture whose supporting structure and political context has disappeared.  They are essentially an orphaned culture, destined to disappear - as it largely has, except for the rather broad brush stroke version that remains, having lost much of its subtleties.   In this, Tanpınar stands before his time in that, with the global expansion of Western culture, corporatism and Western consumerism, most of us now live in an orphaned or dying culture, or wholly within the post-national consumerist universe (not counting the cartoon versions of national culture so popular now with right wing nationalist political movements).

References:

Song in Mahur - Refik Talat Alpman?

Makams - key modes/moods in Ottoman music - Ferahfeza, Acemaşıran, Beyatı, Sultaniyegah, Nühüft, Mahur

Tab'i Mustafa Efendi - composer (nothin on Youtube - check Neyzen for his hicaz saz semaisi

Ismail Dede Efendi - composer


Thursday, 31 January 2019

How Democracies Die - Steven Levitsky & Daniel Ziblatt

A very interesting, concise and well-written look at the phenomenon of the elected officials who slide their democratic systems into what is essentially a dictatorship.
The authors clearly outline four essential elements, though every "elected" dictator doesn't necessarily meet all four criteria.
- disregard for the constitution and the value of elections
- willingness to use violence
- delegitimizing of the opposition
- highjacking the institutions of government and the institutions that provide checks and balances

As they look at these points, they draw clear illustrations of the tactics from various historical and present-day scenarios:  Hitler, Putin, Erdogan, Marcos, Chavez, amongst others.

All of this in the first quarter (or third) of the book.  The rest of the book is taken up with an examination of how these elements have played out within the American system at various historical points, including most recently, Trump.  (I didn't read this section - seemed to be of more interest to Americans specifically.)

Saturday, 26 January 2019

Land of the Blind - Barbara Nadel

Another crime/detective story by Nadel set in Istanbul.  An enjoyable read, as always.  Like a short visit to Istanbul.  Not the most sophisticated fiction, but still enjoyable.  And she certainly knows her Istanbul geography and history, as she uses it in her stories.

Monday, 21 January 2019

Motherland Hotel - Yusuf Atligan

A Turkish novel from 1973.  Bit of a strange novel - for the time, I suspect both certain aspects of the style, and some of the subject matter, were a bit shocking or controversial.  About a small town hotel clerk who is quite bizarre mentally, a bit obsessive.  In the course of the book, he gets worse, finally has some kind of crisis and commits suicide.  For me, not the most interesting storyline.  What is interesting is the evocation of small town life at that time - the people, the cafes, the mood.  Reminds me of some the small Black Sea towns I stayed in back in the lat 70s.  There is also a fair bit about the main character's family history, so you see how the Greek invasion affected the lives of these people living in the interior, not too far from Izmir. 

Wednesday, 5 December 2018

Twenty-five Lectures on Modern Balkan History - Steven W. Sowards

A series of lectures from a university course on the internet:  http://staff.lib.msu.edu/sowards/balkan/

A good general overview from a prof. at an American university - worth noting, as there is less chance of a nationalistic bias, or an underlying ethnic agenda.
Sowards begins with an attempt to find a definition for the term "Balkan" - what exactly is different about this area that sets it apart from Western Europe. 
He mentions how the mountainous terrain tends to isolate populations and make communication between areas, and with the outside world in general, more difficult. He also mentions that generally poorer soil and dryer climate which affects agricultural output, the source of wealth for much of the period in question.  He sees multi ethnicity as playing a role to a degree, and also in Turkish held areas, a tendency to identify by religious affiliation rather than linguistic or ethnic affiliation, which would otherwise form a base for the development of nationalism.
Repeated wars and suppressed revolts over two or three centuries also played a role in keeping populations low, and rural. 

Economic ideas:
Through the 18th and early 19th century (and later) land formed the basis for wealth.  Elites occupied agricultural land at the will of the Sultan, and land was not inheritable (in theory).  The Sultan worked to keep some kind of balance between rural workers and nobles in terms of taxes etc. As central authority broke down in the course of the later 18th and 19th C., local landlords became independent local centres of power, and worked to expand their land holdings.  They also increased the level of taxation in various forms on peasants working the land.  In the later 18th C, landlords began to increase wealth by selling grain, etc. directly to Western European markets, with several important effects.  First, as the West was wealthier, prices on produce rose, and this caused increased poverty in the Balkans.  Second, because the selling was direct, towns did not grow and benefit from increased commerce, so they remained small and poor, with no developing capital in a middle-class base.  Third, as well as exporting, nobles and wealthy landholders began importing cheaper mass produced goods from the West, putting local artisans and craftsmen out of business, again increasing poverty. 
As central authority collapsed further (including the Habsburgs in northern Balkans), and  revolutions against the Ottomans began to occur, like the ones in Serbia and Greece,  the only real change was who occupied the top landholder positions, changing to local strongmen instead of Ottoman officials.  The system itself remained the same.  (I am reminded here of the accounts of Patrick Leigh Fermor's hide across Central Europe in the early 30's.  You see ghosts of this old landed aristocracy still hanging on in Hungary, etc. in his book.)

Monday, 23 April 2018

The Islamic Enlightenment - Christopher de Bellaigue

An interesting look at modernizers and enlightenment figures in Muslim societies from the 1800's on.  He first looks at early figures country by country, and then in the 20th c., switches to a broader perspective as figures and movements become international in influence.  As you read about these figures, you get a sense of how the religious conservatives have fought this movement for the past two centuries.  You also get a sense of how the West's duplicity, naked pursuit of self-interest, and blatant hypocrisy in the region has played into the hands of the conservative religious leaders, discrediting ideas and movements that have any association with the West and the Enlightenment tradition.
A bit too much detail at times, but it is easy to skim over some sections.

Monday, 19 February 2018

Turkey and the West: Fault Lines in a Troubled Alliance - Kemal Kirişci

A depressing book for anyone interested in Turkey as a country and culture.

This book is basically a history of the Turkey's relationship with the Europe and the U.S. from late Ottoman times to the current Erdoğan period.
The book traces periodic shifts from deeper relations with the West to a more distant stance through the whole period.  I was mostly interested in the longer chapters dealing with the AKP, Erdoğan and policy and relations since about 2000.

The book gives a brief but clear account of how Erdoğan has moved over time to eliminate all other power bases both within the country and also within the AKP itself to leave himself holding most of the power at all levels and in all areas.  In essence, creating what is practically one man rule, or a dictatorship.  This in itself, of course, puts him at odds with the basic tenets of the EU, and introduces some hesitancy or conflict into relations with the U.S.

There is also an account of Davutoğlu's influence on foreign policy and regional ambitions.  Turns out both he and Erdoğan are big supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood, and through them partly, fell into the delusion of rebuilding the Ummah and creating a pan-Islamic state covering the Middle East, Central Asia and North Africa. With Turkey at its centre, of course.  Strange dream.  D and E seem to have also fallen into some delusion concerning Turkey's true weight and importance in the region.  Turkey was well-regarded by many in other predominantly Islamic states in the area, especially by reformers, but it turns out this actually had to do with envying the closer relations Turkey was building in the early Erdoğan years with the EU and the U.S., and little to do with the AKP, Erdoğan and internal Turkish politics.  E and D's shift to a more aggressive regional approach, and a more confrontational attitude towards the EU and the U.S, and subsequent worsening of relations with these blocks, has led to a complete evaporation of whatever respect and admiration there was for Turkey in other regional countries.

Interesting fact:  most large business organizations  do not support the current AKP foreign policies.  Bad for trade with the EU, their prime trading partner.

It seems Erdoğan has painted himself into a bit of a corner with his nationalist rhetoric.  Turkey needs the EU and the U.S. for economic survival, but his base depends on his extreme nationalist posturing and rhetoric.  Makes for difficult management of relations, economic and otherwise.  (Kind of like Trump with American allies and neighbours.)

One other point of interest - the author comes down on the side of mostly blaming Europe for the failure of Turkey's EU accession talks, which have in part fuelled Erdoğan's foreign policies and rhetoric.   Culturocentrism and religiocentrism. 

Monday, 6 November 2017

The Red-haired Woman - Orhan Pamuk

A novel split in two parts.  The first is an exploration of the concept of father/father figure, which is an important figure in many countries, especially in today's more fascistic political climate.  This is obviously tied to contemporary social and political issues in Turkey, as well as a certain social analysis. 
The second part of the book brings in many issues current is Turkey, especially Istanbul.  The main character becomes a property developer, and many of the shady, insider "trading" elements of behind the scenes Istanbul politics appear in the novel.  Pamuk also continues to chronicle the destruction of beautiful Istanbul - the same property development, the choking traffic.  There is also an exploration of loss of values - egocentrism, luxury consumerism, money obsession, an obsession with the West (or some idealized vision thereof).  He also continues his blending of West and East culturally, with specific artwork from both traditions playing a role in the book. 

Interesting and complex.  Worth the read.  Unfortunately, the first half seemed a better read to me than the second half - the second half tends to be a bit too didactic at times, a bit too artificially a novel of ideas.


Friday, 3 November 2017

Border - Kapka Kassabova

Part travelogue, part self-reflective inner journey.   I am not sure about this using of place almost as a metaphor for some internal landscape of self-exploration, and self-expression, examination of inner conflict and emotions.
What make this book interesting is the setting - the border area between Bulgaria, Turkey and Greece.  This is an area with a very charged history, from Ottoman times, through the Balkan Wars, and into the 20th C Cold War period.    Kassabova does explore some interesting places in the Rhodopes in both Greece and Bulgaria.  She also explores some interesting sounding areas in the Strandzha area of Bulgaria, and also just on the other side of the border in Turkey.  All places I would like to visit. 
A very topical book, with all the current issues around migration, border crossing, etc.  Much of it currently set in the very area she explores in the book.