Search This Blog

Showing posts with label islam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label islam. Show all posts

Monday, 28 June 2021

Samarkand - Amin Malouf

 A novel built around an imagined life of Omar Khayyam.  

This is the second time I have read this novel, and I found it much less compelling than the first time I read it.  No doubt, partly because of a waning of my interest in the history of Iran and Central Asia, and also the understanding that very few, if any, traces of this world remain.

Basically, though, it is the style of the novel that I can't relate to.  It seems very much a 19th century novel  The style is somewhat formal, the vocabulary a bit recherche.  The characters are also somewhat exaggerated caricatures of types:  the mysterious persian princess, the american man of reason, the conniving eastern potentate, the clear-eyed bon vivant, etc.  The emotional tone of the characters is also to monochromatic and high - love, regret, righteous indignation, all with capital letters.  In sum, it reads too much like a 19th century moral tale.  Also, like a 19th century romantic tale with love pursued and lost, with nostalgic regret.  

Unfortunate, because what Malouf is trying to do is important.  Through his novels, he is trying to portray a Middle East and Islamic world that the West is ignorant of.  He wants to show that there is more to the Middle East than religious fundamentalism, ignorant sectarianism and self-righteous moralizing.  As he shows, there has always been a conflict between narrow-minded religious dogmatism and more enlightened, reasoned, humanistic visions, but the currently dominant fundamentalism was not always the most powerful view.  

Monday, 23 April 2018

The Islamic Enlightenment - Christopher de Bellaigue

An interesting look at modernizers and enlightenment figures in Muslim societies from the 1800's on.  He first looks at early figures country by country, and then in the 20th c., switches to a broader perspective as figures and movements become international in influence.  As you read about these figures, you get a sense of how the religious conservatives have fought this movement for the past two centuries.  You also get a sense of how the West's duplicity, naked pursuit of self-interest, and blatant hypocrisy in the region has played into the hands of the conservative religious leaders, discrediting ideas and movements that have any association with the West and the Enlightenment tradition.
A bit too much detail at times, but it is easy to skim over some sections.

Tuesday, 12 December 2017

The Ways of Strangers - Graeme Wood

This book is purportedly a look into the kind of people that support and sign up for ISIS.  In fact, it ends up being a bunch of interviews with armchair jihadis who sit at home in the West and write rabid material for ISIS websites.  Each one has a valid (?) excuse for why they can't actually go and join the jihad in Syria...   Intellectual wankers who run no risk of getting their hands dirty.  The proposed topic would have been much more interesting...

Sunday, 24 September 2017

The End of Europe - James Kirchick

Subtitiled "Dictators, Demagogues, and the Coming Dark Age"  Published in 2017

Kirchick looks at a number of European issues through the lens of specific countries and their problems.  Some of the problems he discusses include neutrality as a stance and how it encourages Russian aggression and meddling, the rise of antisemitism and the failure to integrate Muslim immigrants into the European system of values (also seen as a failure to manage immigration as an issue in general), the desire for European wealth without European values and fiscal discipline, the failure to stand firm on state borders and state protection (again in the face of Russian aggression), the pursuit of self-interested economic gains at the expense of other EU states.  Basically the failure to act as a mutually supportive group, and to blame others for the problems of one's own political culture and economy.
For me, the most troubling tendency is the rise of apologists for Russian aggression and interference.  This shows a singular stupidity in relation to even recent history, especially when you see such tendencies in former East Bloc countries.  True, the US has looked after its interests in helping develop the European project, but the net effect has been mutual benefit (unlike some other places where the US has been active...).  People have also forgotten that Europeans have twice in the past century called on the US to help them clean up a mess of their own making, at the price of many American lives.  This gives them the right to participation.  The Russia project, on the other hand, has never been about mutual benefit for the larger population of other countries, something the corrupt elites in many European countries seem to have grasped.  Their Russian apologist stance is based on narrow self-interest or crony interest.   The Russian project has no ideological cover now - oligarchy, corruption, power.
Also the ability to suppress core social values when face with cultural relativism.

Two things that bothered me at first are the usual problems with many US political thinkers.  First, they are blind to the US' use of many practices that they criticize in relation to Russia.  Second, they are blindly pro-Israel and pro-Zionist, and are blind to the many machinations that Israel and Zionist groups in other countries use to stifle criticism and discussion.

While these issues are technically outside the focus of this book, they need to be acknowledged to give the criticisms levies some legitimacy.  Especially true considering the current (as of publication) US president embodies many of the same issues and uses many of the same disinformation techniques discussed in the book.

Worth reading, especially alongside the recently read discussion of major US failings,  Time to Start Thinking, by Edward Luce.

Wednesday, 24 August 2016

Iran in World History - Richard Foltz

A well-written overview of the basic events and movements in the history of Iran.  Just enough detail.  Excellent for general interest.  From 3500 BC to the present.
It also provides some insight into the long-lasting underlying forces in Iranian politics and history - the rise of clerical power, the link between the landowner class and the clerical establishment, and their resistance to political and social change.

There is also an interesting mention of Mithraism and its influence on Jews living within the Sassanian empire leading to some central concepts in the emergence of Christianity.


To find:

Hushang Golshiri - modern novelist


Thursday, 26 May 2016

Silk Roads: A New History of the World - Peter Frankopan

An excellent new look at the history of Central Asia and the Silk Road.  Frankopan begins the book with a brief chronological overview and then moves on to look at the movement of goods and ideas from the Far East to Europe from several points of view - luxury goods exchange, idea exchange, culture exchange, religion exchange, slave exchange, disease and plague exchange.  He also pursues the topic beyond the traditional overland route and includes the move to trade by long distance European sailing ships in the concept of Silk Road.  He pursues it into the modern age, looking at the Suez Canal and the eventual Suez Canal crisis as part of the history of the Silk Road.  The book continues right up to contemporary times where Central Asia is undergoing a little recognized renaissance as a trading centre due to its rich natural resources - overlooked perhaps because the benefits largely seem to accrue to the top social echelons, which is actually the traditional wealth distribution structure in Central Asia way back to early Silk Road times.

He also notes patterns in this trade route through the ages - the importance of slave trading as a generator of wealth and capital at the beginning of each group's period of dominance - arabs, Vikings, Europeans.  The tendency of wealth to accrue at the top of society.

Worth rereading.

Monday, 31 August 2015

Disordered World - Amin Maalouf

Subtitled "Setting a New Course for the Twenty-first Century"

An interesting analysis of the current Middle East and where we find ourselves in general today. Maalouf has the advantage of having witnessed first hand the breakdown of social order and the slip into chaos in Lebanon.
He looks at how the West has misused its strength and created political and social disasters in countries in the Middle East, and indirectly helped create Islamic fundamentalism.  He has a long chapter on how political leaders everywhere have lost any sense of legitimacy in the eyes of their people by being tied to narrow special interests of all stripes.  He also talks about how a post-ideological world has fractured into a tribal world based on ethnicity, religion, skin colour, wealth.

He finishes the book with some chapters on how to rebuild, on how to reestablish a solidarity that can transcend cultures, ethnicities and religion.  Very idealistic.  Based on values of culture (I am reminded here of the effect on culture and its values of the cataclysm of WW I).
It is a nice vision, but I am more inclined to agree with Zizek's idea that change to the system will only come after collapse into chaos, probably provoked by environmental crises.

I find his non-fiction style a bit heavy and pedantic, but the ideas are interesting.

Worth rereading.

Monday, 8 June 2015

The Lonely War - Nazila Fatih

Subtitled "One Woman's Account of the Struggle for Modern Iran".
What makes this book so interesting is the contextualization of modern Iranian history and politics through Nazila Fatih's life as a reporter on Iran for the New York Times.
It provides insights into the social realities of Iran during the revolutionary period and also the shift in those realities with the passage of time.  It also shows the complexity of the political culture in Iran.  Contrary to Western images, it is not a monolithic dictatorial state structure; there are different branches in the government and they have their different agendas and different relationships to the modernizing movements in Iran.  These branches can be at cross purposes and even work against each other in the many surveillance and prosecutorial activities.
The recent unrest and violence in Iran has been caused by this type of conflict between different branches of the government with varying levels of support from the people of Iran.  The diehard conservative element is headed by Khamenei - this group traces its roots back to the early days of the revolution (though they no longer have much support from the clergy in Qom, who see the need to modernize Shia Islam practice in Iran).  Without support of the people and their "democratically" elected representatives, Khamenei has created an oppresssive force with the Revolutionary Guard and the Basij.  This is a client relationship in that Khamenei can use oil revenue to provide benefits and perks in exchange for their support.  On the other side are the main body of clergy, the reformists (both secular and religious, and some even tracing their roots back to Khomeni and the original revolution),  the democratically elected Parliament, and the majority of the people.

This situation is another example of the saying, "Absolute power corrupts absolutely". Khomein set up the system so that the absolute power of last word rests with the religious leader of the country.  This amount of power contains an invitation to abuse.  Khamenei is abusing this absolute power to keep himself and his small group in power against the will of the people.  The goal becomes, not just government for the good of the people (however you define it), but the maintenance and continuance of power for its own sake.

Monday, 18 May 2015

Pakistan: A Hard Country - Anatol Lieven

Recommended by Mohsin Hamid.
A very interesting read about a very complex country.  Lieven clearly lays out the complexities of family, tribal, regional and social class relations with Pakistani society.  He underlines all the divisions, conflicting agendas and endgames that complicate political, social and even personal lives. He makes it abundantly clear that Pakistan is not a jihadi monolith as reported in the West, but is in fact a rich, multilayered, complex society.  On top of the tribal and familial complexities you also have to lay over that eastern/middle eastern thing of the dichotomy of reality as idealized and discussed in public space vs. reality at the personal action and decision level.

This is a society and political system built on a basis completely different from Western societies.  It is far more complex than our social structures - I think we would be lost if we had to try and navigate in that social and political world.   Our western politicians and foreign policy must seem like bulls in a china shop to them.  It is abundantly clear after reading this book that our concepts of democracy and the free market don't have much place in that social world.  As concepts they may be adopted, but would become so changed in practice I don't think we would recognize them.

I suspect the same holds true for a country like Egypt.

Thursday, 19 March 2015

Discontent and Its Civilizations - Mohsin Hamid

A collection of wide-ranging essays, from personal to political.

For me, the most interesting are the essays focusing on presenting a deeper, more nuanced picture of Pakistan, and by extension, Islam.

Underlying a lot of his thought is the idea that civilizations are an illusion.  They are stories that are told, often for a political end, or from a position of weakness.  He explores the idea of the complexity and multi-layerd nature of identities,  (This is a theme I read about recently in another book.)  This idea also links into the idea I have been mulling over lately of the possibility of living without stories, without a personal mythology - is it possible?  Or can you simply change your relation to stories and mythology, seeing them less as a definition of self and the world, and more as something to play with, to take on and off, like glasses or costumes?

To Find:
Antonio Tabucchi - Sostiene Pereira (and other works)

Friday, 27 February 2015

The Great War for Civilization - Robert Fisk


A book by a reporter who has covered every major and minor war and conflict in the Middle east for decades.  A sickening and depressing look at what went on in Iraq (twice), Algeria (twice), Palestine, Armenia, Afghanistan.  He looks at corruption in U.S. policy, European government policy, Middle-eastern government policy.  He looks at the role of the Saudis in the region.
He catalogues both high level corruption and the sad story of the effects of all of this on the little people in these societies.

Then of course, there are the accounts of the three interviews he did with Osama Bin Ladin - I believe the only journalist from the West to interview Bin Ladin, and certainly the only one to be invited by Bin Ladin to do the interview.

Having witnessed all of that, I don't understand how he can continue on and not be crushed by all the horror and injustice he has witnessed.

Wednesday, 11 February 2015

The Reluctant Fundamentalist - Mohsin Hamid

A short but very intense novel.  Well-crafted book built on a long monologue conversation in a market in Lahore between a Pakistani former New York financial analyst and what appears to be a CIA agent, though this is never made clear.

It explores issues that came up around the 9/11 event - the role of the US internationally and Corporate America's economic and social effect on countries around the world.  Through his time in Princeton and on Wall Street, he presents a social picture of the upper financial stratum of the US and both its privileged position and the privileges it takes for granted as its right.  This analysis is critical but subtle - worth reflecting on.  There is also an attempt to draw awareness to the kinds of stereotyped images in the US media of other countries around the world and what life is like there.

A subtle book - rare, so worth rereading.

Friday, 9 January 2015

Islamic Patterns: An Analytical and Cosmological Approach - Keith Critchlow

A fascinating look at the underlying geometry and design principles of traditional islamic decorative patterns.  There are many examples of how the patterns are built geometrically through several steps and transformations.  Watching the shapes go through their transformations and patterns is fascinating.

Another intriguing element in the book is the cosmology and philosophy behind these patterns.  They are not just decorative; they also express a profound world view.  They are seen as an expression of the One, the unity in all things.  Through geometry, the circle, the square and the triangle become one, interconnected variations on the theme of Oneness, with the circle as the most primal or basic form.  There are strong links to the Pythagorean theory and cosmology of numbers.

To find:
Pythagorean cosmology and number theory

Tuesday, 6 January 2015

The Honey Thief - Najaf Mazari, Robert Hillman

A wonderful collection of short stories set in the Hazara area of Afghanistan.  The author is Hazara and manages to catch a wonderfully guileless voice in these stories, a voice from another time and another life.  Some of the stories cross each other in time or with characters.
The effects of all the war and turmoil appear in the story, but they do not dominate - they are a background against which the characters must live their lives.
This book also offers a different image of practicing Muslims than you usually meet in the media these days.
Another interesting element of this book is the stories portraying a Muslim people living close to nature and in an intimate relationship with their surroundings - this is unusual.  It provides and interesting contrast to the portrayals of native peoples of North America and Australia.

The author's story is also interesting and worth checking out on the Internet.

Friday, 31 October 2014

Masterpieces of Islamic art : the decorated page from the 8th to the 17th century - Oleg Grabar

An excellent collection of large colour reproductions.  Well worth tracking down.  With a magnifying glass, you can examine the amazing details in these works.

My Name is Red - Orhan Pamuk

This being the second or third time I've read this book, I can say you don't really appreciate the charm of it until you get past the rather convoluted and sketchy storyline.  The real charm of it is 1) the evocation in small details of historical Istanbul, its neighbourhoods and people  2) the information and reflections on the the nature, history and working methods of Islamic illuminated manuscripts  3) the subtle discussion of the push and pull of West and East in Turkish history (and modern Turkey).  He tries to portray a world view, a way of thinking, that is essentially lost.

A book to reread while leafing through a good collection of Islamic miniatures - it gives a new perspective on the paintings.


Sunday, 31 August 2014

Al Qaeda and What It Means to be Modern - John Gray

The first part of this book presents in an organized way his ideas on the various aspects of the Enlightenment, and how they have informed not only modern capitalism, but also communism and also modern forms of extremism based on the remaking of man and society or the rule of pure  reason.  While I find it a bit shallower than his usual vignette style of presenting and interweaving various threads of ideas, it is presented in a clearer form.

Unfortunately, the last half of the book rambles and rants a bit.  He falls into various (delirious) imaginings of the future, and it begins to sound a  bit "mullah-ish", ranting with the pointer finger raised etc.


Monday, 7 July 2014

The State of Egypt - Alaa Al Aswany

A collection of what are probably newspaper editorials written in the years preceding the 2012 Egyptian revolution.
It covers the same social criticism as his novels but in non-fiction form.  An interesting companion to his novels, but his novels are richer.

Monday, 23 June 2014

War Peace and War: The Rise and Fall of Empires - Peter Turchin

Fascinating new perspective on cycles in history.
He looks at long cycles in history from several points of view which overlap.

His first idea is that empires and dominant civilizations arise at points where two distinct cultural and social groups meet.  This clash of groups heightens intragroup identity and creates a one for all, all for one survival mentality.  This is how a smaller cultural group can coalesce and in the end defeat a much larger rival culture with a weaker intragroup identity.  He calls this intragroup dynamic the group's "asabiya".  As examples of this phenomenon he examines in detail the Roman Empire, looks at the Cossack expansion east and south, and also examines the rise of the Carolingian Empire in Medieval Europe.  Convincingly argued.  A dominant civilization's cycle can last for 1000 years even, with some up and down cycles along the way.

The next cycle he looks at he refers to as a secular cycle (there is a recent book with this title).  This is essentially an economic cycle but with cumulative social consequences.  It is a cycle where economic inequality increases over time due to various social and political processes that seem to be hard to regulate.  At the same time, there is a disproportionate growth of numbers in the elite of society.  In the end there is a shortage of resources for everyone - the bottom end of society has limited economic resources; the elites have little opportunity for advancement and limited access to political power.  This leads to a weakening of group asabiya, a breakdown in social cooperation, increased conflict and finally revolution, civil war or some such catastrophe.  This phase continues until everyone is thoroughly sick of it.  War and subsequent disease, disorder and famine, eventually reduce the number of elites and the number of people in general, and there is a return to cooperation and a more equitable distribution of wealth simply because there is now a higher proportion of opportunities and resources available to everyone.
This secular cycle however, eventually weakens the group asabiya to the point where it can no longer be rebuilt and the civilization crumbles, fades, in subsumed by another new stronger group.

He also has an interesting section on southern Italy and how lost its asabiya centuries ago due to repeated conquering by foreign rulers.  It is essentially a look at how it can be next to impossible to rebuild asabiya, trust, a civil society once it is gone.

This book provides and interesting perspective on current social and political events around the world.  It offers a very long view framework into which these short-term events and trends can be placed.  For me, it provides some intriguing points from which to think about what is going on economically and politically in our own western societies and in other societies around the world.

Worth owning for occasional dipping and refreshing.




Saturday, 22 February 2014

Lost Enlightenment - Central Asia's Golden Age from the Arab Conquest to Tamerlane - S. Frederick Starr

A fascinating account of one of the great forgotten ages (and regions) of intellectual and artistic achievement.  A worthwhile read for a number of reasons:

- the sheer contrast of the historical region with its current state
- the tantalizing hints of what must have been there as an intellectual and artistic tradition before the arab invasion, which was really the arrival of the barbarians by then central asian standards
- the underlying theme of the importance of persian culture and cultures of the persian linguistic families in the flowering of this great age; underlines that this culture was a highly influential culture in the whole middle-eastern and central asian region
- the historical importance of this central asian intellectual tradition to the later flowering of european thought and development, both as a source of ideas and as a source of ancient texts 
- Starr's speculations on the reason for the decline of the region:  increasing focus on religious dogmatism in a conflict between the two versions of Islam leads to intolerance and a narrowing of the field of thought - something to consider in this age of dogmatisms, religious, cultural, social, political as so on...
- Starr's observation that, even excluding the possible highly advanced society preceding the arab invasion, this Central Asian Golden Age lasted longer than any other similar historical golden period in any other society world-wide
- great source for thinkers and poets to chase down

This book is a great reference to put any writers (Rumi, Khayam etc.) in their political and social context.

Not a fast read, as it is very detailed and explores central intellectual themes as well as social, political, and economic milieux.