Search This Blog

Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Friday, 2 October 2026

Goliath's Curse - Luke Kemp

  Estoy leyendo un libro sobre las causas de la caída de las sociedades y civilizaciones.  Se llama, Goliath's Curse.  El estudio  inicia muy lejos en la historia con la desaparición de los Neandertales y continúa hasta hoy en día.

En los que concierne a los Neandertales, no hay un acuerdo general de la causa de su desaparición.  Existen diversas teorías posibles, pero me parece muy probable que todos los elementos sugeridos como causas jueguen un papel.  Pero, el autor de este libro propone una nueva idea vinculada a las relaciones sociales de los Neandertales.  Sus relaciones parecen haber sido muy diversas de las de Homo Sapiens.  El examen genético de sus huesos sugiere que vivieron en grupos muy aislados con poco contacto con otros grupos.  El material genético de ellos es bastante limitado.  Por otro lado, parece que los grupos de Homo Sapiens vivieron con mucho contacto, mucho cambio genético con otros grupos.  Esta diferencia dió a los Homo Sapiens dos grandes ventajas.  Primero, una más grande variedad genética ayuda a los grupos a sobrevivir a enfermedades y también estrés ambiental.  La segunda ventaja es la del aprendizaje.  Nuevas invenciones, nuevas herramientas, nuevas maneras de vivir y de cazar pasaron rápidamente entre los diversos grupos.  Más importante, según el autor, esta sociabilidad sería uno de los elementos prototípicos de los Homos Sapiens como especie.  Contribuye al avance muy rápido de la cultura y la tecnología, y según el autor, también a la formación muy temprana de sociedades y civilizaciones autocráticas.  

Otra característica básica de nuestra especie que menciona el autor es el rechazo de la dominación por otros, por lo menos por la mayoría de sus miembros.  Preferimos vivir en situaciones sociales pero sin autoridades que impongan sus ideas y deseos.  Según las investigaciones arqueológicas, muchas antiguas sociedades y reinos (aquí, sobre todo en América Central) inician como conglomeraciones más o menos iguales, pasan por un periodo de centralización de poder y control para terminar con la elección de un gran parte de la población de irse para escapar de una autoridad que se volvió demasiado pesada.  A veces, parece que hubo también revoluciones con masacres de las elites y la destrucción de su arquitectura imperial.   En cada caso, era un rechazo a la autoridad central excesiva.  

Hasta ahora, vemos la interacción de dos impulsos opuestos, el de la sociabilidad, y el del deseo de libertad personal.  Pero, con el desarrollo de la agricultura, entra otro elemento que cambió totalmente la dinámica.  Antes, cuando los miembros de un grupo de caza no estaban contentos de su situación, podían simplemente irse.  La caza se hacía por todos partes, y sus bienes eran fácilmente transportables.  Pero, con el desarrollo de la agricultura, la gente está mucho más vinculada a un lugar particular para producir su comida.   La agricultura necesita una inversión de tiempo y necesita más herramientas.  Esta inmovilidad introduce ciertas vulnerabilidades.  Si en el grupo, hay alguien que quiere expandir su poder en el grupo y controlar más cosas y personas, ahora no es posible para la gente irse fácilmente si no esta contenta de esta nueva situación.  

Aquí el autor habla mucho de un grupo de característicos personales conocido como la triada oscura - un deseo exagerado de poder y estatus o un egoísmo exagerado, manipulador, y psicópata.  Parece que hasta el 10 por ciento de la sociedad demuestra estas características.  Este 10 por ciento, incluso hoy en día, se encuentra sobre todo en los campos de la política y las posiciones ejecutivas.  Es decir que, con esta nueva inmovilidad, las sociedades se hicieron más susceptibles a ser controladas por este tipo de personas.

Este último punto también está vinculado al otro cambio, el del desarrollo de la agricultura.  La agricultura permite la acumulación de bienes, sobre todo de comida como el grano.  El grano es un bien que es fácil robar.  Para las comunidades controladas por un jefe, aprovechar este grano acumulado de otras comunidades es una manera de enriquecerse, aumentar su estatus, y expandir su poder.  Entonces, llega la guerra.

Para motivar a sus jóvenes a participar en estas guerras, necesita inventar historias que les convenzan de que los otros son peligrosos o inferiores, y que su sociedad es superior y tiene más derechos que los otros.  Como humanos, tenemos una tendencia natural de inventar, casi necesitar, historias para explicar lo que sucede alrededor de nosotros.  Esta tendencia nos hace susceptibles a las historias inventadas por los grupos en poder para justificar su posición superior y también sus agresiones contra los otros grupos.

Hay otros puntos en el libro, pero estos son, para mí, los principales.  

En suma, lo que es interesante, es que, por causa de ciertos elementos básicos de la nuestra naturaleza y desarrollo - sociabilidad, inventores de historias, inventores de la agricultura, este 10% que son psicópatas -  parece casi inevitable que terminemos viviendo en sociedades autoritarias.


Desafortunadamente, la segunda mitad del libro es muy diversa.  Cuando inicia a hablar del futuro, y hacer predicciones alrededor del IA y los peligros que presenta, cae en este genere de predicción de apocalipsis.  No es una explicación racional e investigada, sino se vuelve en especulaciones puras.  (Lo que es extraño, porque en la primera parte del libro, habla de como los autoritarios usan el miedo para controlar y dirigir sus sociedades.               

          


Thursday, 10 June 2021

The Archipelago: Italy Since 1945 - John Foot

 An excellent, well-written account of Italian politics and society post-war.  Covers the social conflicts between workers/Communist party and Industrialists/Christian Democrats/ex-Fascists through the 40s, 50s and 60s.  Also includes a specific discussion of how the Americans worked to influence the first post-war elections to ensure the Communist party did not win the national elections.  (Both of these preceding points seem to be mostly forgotten by most Italians I speak with, even the educated ones.)  Chronicles the continual ties between governments and the mafia.  Excellent account of the emergence of the Lega, which has been around as a separatists, racist party for decades.  The biggest surprise was the account of Berlusconi and the Berlusconi years.  Berlusconi was basically a Trump without Twitter.  Same use of media to bypass the party system and speak directly to an alienated popular base.  Same subversion of the party system to make it a one man show.  Same view of government as a tool for furthering his business interests and those of his close allies.  Same attempts to change the laws to avoid persecution for his corrupt business dealings.  

In the end, it is a pretty hopeless picture, with a cross-party group of elites at all levels of business and government, including the judicial system, that work to protect each other and maintain their positions of power.    

Tuesday, 1 December 2020

The WEIRDEST People in the World - Joseph Henrich

 A potentially fascinating book exploring the psychological and conceptual differences between the Western European psyche and culture and that of the rest of the world, and how this helps explain the rise and dominance of the West.  He looks at all kinds of things - individualism vs. social and familial integration,  social cohesion vs. individual perception and judgement, the locus of causality and guilt, and many others.

One interesting point that he makes is how the Catholic Church revolutionized social relations in the West by forbidding cousin marriage, thereby forcing people to reach out beyond their immediate familial circles to develop a wider web of relations.

Unfortunately, the book delves into the background, research and experiments a bit too deeply and it begins to drag.  I would like to read a version with the main themes and conclusions and a simple summary of the background related to each.  Because of this quality, I couldn't finish the book.

Try again, reading only the beginning and end of each section for the main points and themes.

Saturday, 3 October 2020

Todo Modo - Leonardo Sciascia

 Corto romanzo di tipo critica sociale.  Esamina il rapporto corrotto tra la Chiesa, il mondo degli affari e delle grande imprese, e del governo sociale cristiano.  Da un certo punto di vista, espone il tentativo della Chiesa, ora forza metà spenta, di ritenere il possibile della sua importanza e del suo potere.

Interessante come documento sociale di un certo periodo storico.

Conversazione in Sicilia - Elio Vittorini

 Il romanzo classico di Vittorini.  Bella storia del ritorno alla Sicilia dopo anni d'assenza.  Ha elementi surreale e anche molto concreti e realistici.  L'avevo letto molti anni fa, ma questa volta ho notato più chiaramente gli elementi politici ed antifascisti nel romanzo.  Ero anche impressionato dall'umanesimo dell'autore, perfino davanti ai due fascisti che incontra durante il suo viaggio in treno.  Abbastanza facile di lettura, e di un'apparente semplicità, ma con bellissime imagine ed intrecci di temi. 

Certo vale la pena di rileggerlo più di una volta.

Saturday, 23 November 2019

Agent Running in the Field - John LeCarré

Another great book by this author.  The contemporary issues underlying this current book are both very topical and demonstrate more perception than current media or public awareness.
1 - how the English elite, and particularly the London financial system, has turned into an enabler for, and profits hugely from, vast sums of money coming out of criminal regimes and being parked for security in London banks and property.  Particularly from Eastern Europe.  Le Carré's point is that this lucrative relationship has started to colour and control England's diplomatic and international agenda.

2 - the possibility of a U.S. England alliance designed to destabilize and ultimately destroy the E.U. as an institution through fake news, provocations, support for far right groups.  This idea is highly plausible.  Brexiteers see the E.U. as a threat to their agenda.  Trump and the American Right see the E.U. as an economic and political threat in an arena where for the past fifty years they have controlled the playing field.  The Anglo socio-political world view - every man for themselves, wealth as a legitimizer of power - stands in opposition to the E.U.'s more socialist leanings.  Just as the West once stood as a stark contrast to the ugliness of the Soviet regime, Europe's more humane and inclusive politics stand in stark contrast to the growing social ugliness of the Anglo political world.  In a sense, the U.S. and England are now on the same side as Putin in relation to the E.U.   Another interesting little aside in the novel is the author's comment that Trump says the things about the E.U. that Putin can't say as he attempts to weasel his way deeper into the economics and politics of the region.

This is LeCarré's most disturbing book so far, from the point of view of issues he examines.  I suppose because the central conflict is entirely located within what would have formerly been seen as the Free World.  It suggests that, rather than having disappeared with the fall of the Soviet Union, the rot has in fact spread into Europe and the U.S..

Tuesday, 1 October 2019

This Is Not Propaganda: Adventures in the War Against Reality - Peter Pomerantsev

  A complex exploration of how our communication has moved away from facts and reality to the fantasy worlds of Facebook and Twitter.  Looks at social and economic causes.
Some interesting examinations of how totalitarian forces have coopted the language and gestures of the Left to counter their influence.
  Some scary case studies of how Facebook and Twitter have been used by would-be dictators and extremists to control people's perception of reality, to win elections and to create riots and commit murder.

  Worth rereading, as ideas are quite complex and wide-ranging.

Monday, 16 September 2019

The Uses and Abuses of History - Margaret MacMillan

  In spite of the title, a fairly light read looking at the way history is used by politicians and radicals to further their ends.  She outlines some interesting historical myths used in recent history to justify some horrendous actions - Serbia, post-Vichy France - as well as instances where governments have refused to listen to historical experts with specialized knowledge of countries - U.S. policy in the Middle East, especially Iraq. 
  She also discusses the issues around current governments acknowledging responsibility and apologizing for actions done in the past in different times with different values.  There are two sides to this coin.
   Worth a read, but if you are a thinking consumer of the news and history, not much new here.

Thursday, 8 August 2019

How Fascism Works - Jason Stanley

A well-written concise book looking at the way fascism/autocratic forms of government establish themselves in a democratic context.  Step by step, technique by technique analysis.  Reads like a "how to" manual for would-be dictators.
Each critical step draws examples from history, mostly Mussolini and Hitler, and then looks at these same steps being taken currently in various countries around the world from the U.S. to Turkey to Russia to many others.
It is both interesting and useful to look at these steps and ask which ones you see currently operating within your own society.  Kind of a social health check-up. 
Worth reading several times.
Also worth reading in tandem with Ece Temelkuran's recent book, "How to Lose a Country".

How to Lose a Country - Ece Temelkuran

Subtitled "The 7 Steps from Democracy to Dictatorship"
    Brilliant book chronicling Turkey's slide into its current dictatorship/autocracy, with asides looking at the same process in other countries - U.S., Hungary, Russia, Poland, Britain.
She brings up the point that this structure of government can actually be called a form of mafia government.
     A good companion read to "How Fascism Works".
    Temelkuran points out some interesting techniques used by would-be leaders, particularly their use of the news cycle and the outrageous statement as a means to controlling the media's and people's attention, directing it towards controversial topics as the government gets on with some other agenda that it doesn't want attention on.
    A very disturbing book.  You have to worry about your own homeland heading in that direction. So far, Temelkuran has focused on the actions of the would-be dictator as he moves towards absolute power, but I am interested in the ground, the socio-political situation that makes his rise possible, that he exploits on his way up.  My sense is the fertile ground lies in groups that see themselves excluded from the benefits of society as it stands.  And it has to be a significant group in terms of numbers.  When I consider Turkey, Russia and Hungary, it seems that desperate poverty is certainly one of those conditions of exclusion.  Hence, the aspiring fascist/dictator groups get the support of these poor people by simply giving them some of the basic necessities of life for free. (Same thing was done in Egypt by the Muslim Brotherhood - these poor people may not buy into the religious or nationalist message, but they sure appreciate the food and other necessities.)  Or by creating low-paying fake jobs for them - as Orban is doing in Hungary.  This, however, is not one of the basic techniques in the U.S. - their mythology is too strongly against any kind of social welfare...
So you can conclude here that increased income inequality, either within society as a whole or regionally, is one key element that helps prepare the ground for the rise of autocrats.
     Another group to exploit would seem to be the people who see themselves excluded for religious or cultural reasons.  In Turkey, the religious factor is obviously at play in several ways.  First in the former dominance of a secular elite.  Second, in some discriminatory laws around religious clothing that excluded people from higher education and government positions.  Cultural exclusion can also be seen. At play, I suspect, was also a disdain towards the people and society of smaller, more traditional Anatolian towns and villages, which also suffered, coincidentally from higher levels of poverty.  A would-be dictator gets their support by appearing to take them seriously, by speaking their cultural language, by granting them respect.  Which "respect" also seems to be a big selling point for Trump in the eyes of many mid-western and small town Americans (who also experience higher levels of poverty and joblessness.)
    A third issue also seems to be exploitable by would-be autocrats, the issue of "the other", of immigrants, (or of the "foreign" E.U regulations in some European countries).  It is essentially a reverse side of cultural exclusion  - the fear of becoming a cultural stranger in your own country due to immigrant culture or culture imposed from outside. This is the issue that can be used with the middle-class, secular citizen. This trope is being exploited in many countries, but alone it doesn't seem to get the would-be autocrat too far.  Economic exclusion and cultural exclusion seem to be more powerful issues to exploit.

    The other interesting idea she brings up, which is peculiar to our current technology and era, is the idea of the mob - how harsh it can be, how dangerous, how beyond reason.  In situations like that of Turkey (and the U.S.) Twitter etc. essentially function as tools for the formation of mobs at lightening speed.  The mob follows you everywhere because it infiltrates your online life.  It can also easily track your address, your family and connections.  This is a new and very scary tool for enforcing conformism and for silencing dissent through fear.

Thursday, 31 January 2019

How Democracies Die - Steven Levitsky & Daniel Ziblatt

A very interesting, concise and well-written look at the phenomenon of the elected officials who slide their democratic systems into what is essentially a dictatorship.
The authors clearly outline four essential elements, though every "elected" dictator doesn't necessarily meet all four criteria.
- disregard for the constitution and the value of elections
- willingness to use violence
- delegitimizing of the opposition
- highjacking the institutions of government and the institutions that provide checks and balances

As they look at these points, they draw clear illustrations of the tactics from various historical and present-day scenarios:  Hitler, Putin, Erdogan, Marcos, Chavez, amongst others.

All of this in the first quarter (or third) of the book.  The rest of the book is taken up with an examination of how these elements have played out within the American system at various historical points, including most recently, Trump.  (I didn't read this section - seemed to be of more interest to Americans specifically.)

Saturday, 26 January 2019

More Money Than Brains: Why School Sucks, College is Crap, and Idiots Think Their Right - Laura Penny

Another brilliant book by this author.  Same serious research and insightful comments in a witty and humorous style.  Social criticism looking at some of the fundamental attitudes working to dumb down our society, and how we buy into it.  Political and social forces.  Chronicles the shift in our society over the past 40/50 years that has led to a society of ignorance at all levels.
Definitely worth rereading for some choice quotable arguments, stories and facts.

Your Call is Important to Us: the Truth About Bullshit - Laura Penny

Brilliant social analysis in a very witty and irreverent style.  Well-researched, both from a historical perspective and a social trend perspective.  No naive suggestions about how to deal with this, as it is a social problem ie. social trends at large underlie it.
Worth rereading.

Sunday, 23 September 2018

Black Dogs - Ian McEwan

A reread of the first book I read that turned me on to McEwan.  Still a great read.

McEwan does a brilliant job of taking an idea or conflict of ideas and giving it flesh in terms of real characters with real lives.  This book is actually a political allegory, though I see it more clearly this time than I did years ago.  The essential conflict of ideas at the heart of the book is between rationality or reason, and spiritual or religious ways of being in the world.  Interestingly enough, at the end of the book, when June confronts the black dogs of the title, it is this spiritual/religious way of being that chases them away.  At the time of the attack, rationalism is busy studying caterpillars... The author makes it very clear at the end, that the black dogs (left behind by nazis after the war) are a symbol of fascism and all it entails.  Bernard's career, first as a member of the Communist party, and then as a Liberal MP, gets short shrift in terms of significance or value. 
An author you can reread for sure.

Monday, 16 July 2018

Do Not Say We Have Nothing - Madeleine Thien

Brilliant, delicately written book set chronicling a group of intertwined Chinese families during and following the time of the Chinese Cultural Revolution.   The book takes place both in locations in China and in Vancouver. 
In part, the book offers a look at the Cultural Revolution from a human, personal point of view.  I had no idea it was a violent and destructive as it is portrayed in the book.  Thien offers a clear look at the culturally destructive power of this revolution on the arts, educational institutions and cultural traditions of China.  (Mao was unusual in that he managed to enact two horrendously destructive movements in his country - the famine that accompanied the Great Leap Forward, and then this Cultural Revolution.)  You also get a sense of how these type of movements or catastrophes are actually the shadows of struggles for power and dominance in the political elites of dictatorial or oligarchic societies.  Their seeming logic or justification is all afterthought or window dressing for power politics.
Another theme that runs through the book is the power, role and nature of art as a form of resistance and as a support for maintaining personal identity and meaning in mass societies.
Worth checking out more...

Saturday, 23 June 2018

Adjustment Day - Chuck Palahniuk

This book has created quite a bit of controversy with its suggestion in the course of the story that racial groups in the U.S. should inhabit different homelands.  And in fact, the first half of the book reads like a serious, reasonable proposition put forth by a group of essentially white suprematists. 
You have to continue to the last half of the book, however, once the whites, blacks, gays and latinos have all been resettled (or shipped out in the case of the latinos).  As the distinct homelands establish themselves and develop, Palahniuk begins to bring out the essential absurdities of all the current identity politics and doctrines.  Every community becomes a ridiculous and pathetic parody of itself.  In the end, we are left with a small group of fugitives from the various homelands who want to start again in a world where they are not defined by their narrow group identity.
Great sarcasm and parody, but somehow the writing in the last part didn't hold my attention well.

Still worth a read.

Thursday, 3 May 2018

The Constant Gardener - John Le Carré

Typical Le Carré - compelling plot, great characters, and at the same time an exploration of a contemporary issue.  The issue this time is 3rd world development, especially in Africa, and also unscrupulous activity by big pharma, hand in hand with local and international elites.  He explores how shady business practices, bribery and complicity on the part of local and foreign governments allows shocking, at times lethal, practices to continue.  Around the edges you also sense how big corporations, large mafia and top end government and political figures always somehow manage to land on their feet with each others assistance, and the rest of us be damned.  Through one of the main characters, he also explores how indifference, keeping one's head down, and misplaced loyalty make so many lesser figures complicit in this kind of immoral and illegal activity.

Saturday, 31 March 2018

In the Shadows of the American Century - Alfred W. McCoy

A well-researched catalogue of all the conditions and geopolitical shifts that are easing the U.S. out of its position of dominance.
- a brief examination of how the US become so powerful after WW II (economics in a fractured world)
- fracturing of social cohesion at home
- American loss of status and credibility through support for oppressive regimes, use of torture, covert operations harmful to the populations of other countries
- over reliance on military threat to force other countries to acquiesce the US lead / interests
- decline in economic performance (education failure, investment failure)
-decline in share of world economic activity as other countries' economic performance grows

The sections on China are very interesting.   They have a completely different approach to foreign relations.  They use their enormous reserves to build infrastructure partnerships with other countries and improve economies for both partners.   Some of the infrastructure projects are huge:  rail lines to Europe,  high speed rail lines to Europe (China to Berlin in 2 days!)  Infrastructure to link Europe, China and Africa in one large trading block. 

McCoy spends time at the beginning of the book exploring an old idea - Central Asia as the strategic key to world dominance.  If you can control or create a network linking this area with Europe, the East and Africa, then you have the dominant economy in the world.  He sees much of China's foreign policy as working towards this goal.

A book to reread, as there are many threads.

Monday, 19 February 2018

Turkey and the West: Fault Lines in a Troubled Alliance - Kemal Kirişci

A depressing book for anyone interested in Turkey as a country and culture.

This book is basically a history of the Turkey's relationship with the Europe and the U.S. from late Ottoman times to the current Erdoğan period.
The book traces periodic shifts from deeper relations with the West to a more distant stance through the whole period.  I was mostly interested in the longer chapters dealing with the AKP, Erdoğan and policy and relations since about 2000.

The book gives a brief but clear account of how Erdoğan has moved over time to eliminate all other power bases both within the country and also within the AKP itself to leave himself holding most of the power at all levels and in all areas.  In essence, creating what is practically one man rule, or a dictatorship.  This in itself, of course, puts him at odds with the basic tenets of the EU, and introduces some hesitancy or conflict into relations with the U.S.

There is also an account of Davutoğlu's influence on foreign policy and regional ambitions.  Turns out both he and Erdoğan are big supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood, and through them partly, fell into the delusion of rebuilding the Ummah and creating a pan-Islamic state covering the Middle East, Central Asia and North Africa. With Turkey at its centre, of course.  Strange dream.  D and E seem to have also fallen into some delusion concerning Turkey's true weight and importance in the region.  Turkey was well-regarded by many in other predominantly Islamic states in the area, especially by reformers, but it turns out this actually had to do with envying the closer relations Turkey was building in the early Erdoğan years with the EU and the U.S., and little to do with the AKP, Erdoğan and internal Turkish politics.  E and D's shift to a more aggressive regional approach, and a more confrontational attitude towards the EU and the U.S, and subsequent worsening of relations with these blocks, has led to a complete evaporation of whatever respect and admiration there was for Turkey in other regional countries.

Interesting fact:  most large business organizations  do not support the current AKP foreign policies.  Bad for trade with the EU, their prime trading partner.

It seems Erdoğan has painted himself into a bit of a corner with his nationalist rhetoric.  Turkey needs the EU and the U.S. for economic survival, but his base depends on his extreme nationalist posturing and rhetoric.  Makes for difficult management of relations, economic and otherwise.  (Kind of like Trump with American allies and neighbours.)

One other point of interest - the author comes down on the side of mostly blaming Europe for the failure of Turkey's EU accession talks, which have in part fuelled Erdoğan's foreign policies and rhetoric.   Culturocentrism and religiocentrism. 

Friday, 24 November 2017

The Future is History - Masha Gessen

Gessen is basically chronicling the rise of Putin and his mafia don status in Russia.  She narrates the main events and steps leading up to the current situation, starting with the fall of the Soviet Union, and makes the links to economic, political and geopolitical events, and how they affected the development of the current system.
She also includes summaries and discussions of other interesting elements that she sees leading to the rise of Putin.
One interesting sub-theme revolves around the first Russian sociologist to actually conduct surveys to get a sense of the public's view and attitudes, and to chronicle the changes from the 90s on.  (She also discusses the impossibility of sociology as a discipline during Soviet times.)
She also references a number of academics and articles which attempt to define the current Russian system of governance - totalitarian?  fascist?  dictatorship?  Unfortunately none of the source material seems to be available in English.  The one she seems to lean most strongly towards is a mafia system - I tend to agree.  Ideology is irrelevant.  The goal of "governanace" is to increase and control both wealth and power.  The system is run by a Don (Putin) who distributes wealth, power, positions as he sees fit. (And also takes them away when he sees fit.)  Ideology serves as a pacifying or distracting element - new Orthodox religion, family values, anti-immigrant and anti-gay policies.
She also chronicles a return to the Soviet system of almost random intimidation and punishment - the use of gay concept, the ever useful tax evasion charge - as a way of intimidating society to follow the leader and not challenge power.
There is also a psycho-analytical sub-theme, which explores the idea of trauma and how it affects a society, interpersonal relations, etc.  The trauma in this case is, of course, the 18 odd years of terror under Stalin.

I find this particularly interesting, as she is exploring a governance model that is gaining prevalence in many countries currently.  What lies behind the strong man phenomenon.

A complex book with lots of threads and ideas.  Worth rereading, probably several times.